Editorials
August 12, 2008
Red state?
Becoming like Dixie?
Advertisement - Your ad here

Democrats outnumber Republicans in West Virginia nearly 2 to 1 - yet this state voted for the Bush-Cheney presidential ticket in 2000 and 2004. Now, the Mountain State will "go Republican" again in the 2008 race for the White House, experts say.

Five major analyst groups unanimously rank West Virginia as a "red state" solidly favoring Republican John McCain for president, according to a Monday report.

University of Virginia expert Larry Sabato - who spoke in Charleston at the 1996 W.E. "Ned" Chilton III Leadership Lecture - said there's "no real chance for upset" by Democrat Barack Obama in West Virginia.

Congressional Quarterly said West Virginia remains "a Democratic stronghold at almost all other levels," and usually supported Democratic presidential candidates before the 21st century, but now is likely to continue its GOP trend this year. The same conclusion is reached by the Cook Political Report, Pollster.com and the Rothenberg Political Report.

Obviously, West Virginia has many DINOs - Democrats in name only. It's odd that they prefer the shallow president who started the needless Iraq war, who plunged America into ruinous debt through trillion-dollar tax giveaways to the rich, and who stood by as millions of U.S. manufacturing jobs went overseas.

Before a single vote was counted on the 2004 election night, The Associated Press reported that Bush had carried the state. The accurate forecast was based on exit interviews with 1,700 people leaving polls. "Nearly half of all voters identified themselves as evangelical or born-again Christians," the AP wrote, adding that Bush was backed by "those with ardent patriotism and conservative social values such as opposition to abortion and gay marriage."

Will those same values - plus prejudice expressed by some West Virginians in the recent Democratic primary - produce a McCain victory in this state Nov. 4? We hope not.

Dixie once was dominated by DINOs. A half-century ago, the "Solid South" had mammoth Democratic registration - but few genuine Democrats. Most Southern whites held right-wing beliefs. Eventually, they switched alliance, and the South became solid Republican. Is West Virginia following Dixie's path? Or will the Mountain State swing presidential loyalty back to the party that aids average folks?

During the 2004 campaign, a book titled The Great Divide: Retro vs. Metro America said the Democratic Party represents progressive, urban, tolerant, better-educated, equality-minded people (the metro group), while the GOP is backed chiefly by rural, narrow traditionalists (the retro segment), plus the party's historic base, the wealthy.

The book ranked West Virginia among 25 retro states containing 35 percent of U.S. population. It urged the Democratic Party to focus on the 25 metro states with 65 percent of the population, and leave the retro states to the GOP.

We hope this simplistic analysis is erroneous about West Virginia. We hope the experts are wrong about the 2008 presidential outcome. We hope the humane, hardworking, help-the-underdog beliefs of West Virginians keep them in the party that shares those values.

Advertisement - Your ad here
Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: DINO (1:49pm 08-14-2008)
Report Abuse


WV is definitely, Democrate In Name Only. All you have to do is look at agenda pushed and passed by the Governor, Legislators, and local politicians.

I'm a Democrat in a Republican state and have known that for the several years since I returned to WV.

Posted By: Emily (12:21am 08-14-2008)
Report Abuse


Echo, neither candidate believes in protection for unborn children. Will you still vote Repug?

Posted By: Lori (8:59am 08-14-2008)
Report Abuse


Since President Bush took office, I have seen my disposible income dry up. There is no money to save, use for repairs to the home, or anything. We pay over 4000 a year for health insurance, but I still have paid 1000 in copays and still owe about 700. Is it socialist to want our government to put regulations on big companies to keep them from ripping off the public? Look at our colleges. They are in cahoots with the publishing companies so that they change the books every year or so so that students can't buy used books to save money. Why do hospitals have to be for profit? Why is there a war on drugs? We all know what happened during prohibition. That was wherethe rise of orginized crime came about. The war on terrorism must be a farse. Our borders and ports are still not secure. I support Obama, but I will continue to hold my representatives accountable. There is nothing to fear but fear itself.

Posted By: wvcitizen (7:24am 08-14-2008)
Report Abuse


I guess so, if you consider McCain a real republican. But he's not. He is a neoconservative and is considering having Lieberman as his running mate. That says everything.

It's easy to follow the top stories with home delivery of The Charleston Gazette.

Click here to order home delivery.

Advertisement - Your ad here