May 5, 2010
Byrd calls for re-examination of state's relationship with coal
Advertiser

Read the entire statement: 

CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- Sen. Robert C. Byrd on Wednesday called for a reconsideration of West Virginia's relationship with coal mining, saying the industry can't be allowed to dominate the state's politics while causing needless deaths and environmental damage.

"Coal brings much needed jobs and revenue to our economy," the West Virginia Democrat wrote in a new commentary. "But the industry has a larger footprint, including inherent responsibilities that must be acknowledged by the industry."

Byrd issued the piece in response to the nation's worst coal-mining disaster in 40 years, the April 5 explosion that killed 29 miners at Massey Energy's Upper Big Branch Mine in Raleigh County.

"As we seek to understand how and why the Upper Big Branch disaster occurred, we might also re-examine conventional wisdom about the future of the coal industry in our state," Byrd said.

The new commentary comes five months after Byrd issued another strongly worded statement that urged the coal industry to "embrace the future," by accepting the need for action to stem global warming and not demonizing citizens who want to curb mountaintop removal mining.

In the new commentary, Byrd argued that coal is "our birthright" as West Virginians and noted the many existing programs that try to share the wealth created by the industry.

"Indeed, the coal severance tax codifies the philosophy that coal belongs to all West Virginians, and that they deserve meaningful compensation through its extraction," Byrd said. "This philosophy has also been embraced nationwide, through the Black Lung Excise Tax, the Abandoned Mine Reclamation Fee, and several other existing and proposed programs that provide additional compensation to the people and places that produce our coal, oil, gas and other energy resources."

But Byrd said that the coal industry "must respect the miner and his family."

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: Jack__4 (3:10am 05-17-2010)
Report Abuse


MU: You can take your choice, this country controlled by We The People under the Constitution or a freak like Steve Forbes and Bushlt.
I don't know what battle you are talking about, but I would guess that the U.S. won, We The People.
When We The People put in motion the Nations Laws under the Constitution, it did place this Country under the government. A strong
central government.
When an industry like the underground coal mining industry shows that it can't operate under the law, that privilege should be taken away. A business should not have power over We The People. No business should be to big to break or to big to fail.
There is no commerce that is't regulated by our government. We not only regulate business, but we also protect it.
Business will not survive w/out the people (consumer). Business did not evolve into people. The People made business. The People through our government must control big business or we will have another Hoover/ Bushlt depression.

Posted By: WVGazettereader (4:42pm 05-13-2010)
Report Abuse


1 (Red Cross) should be (liable) if they're responsible for training pool manager on pool safety.

2 No one responsible for safety should be in charge of enforcement policies. That's about as stupid as having those responsible for enforcement conducting investigations of accidents.

A-1 Red Cross provides high caliber training for Life Guards, but last I looked there was no job requirement for pool managers. I wish there was as pools are natural places for accidents. Many managers could not even swim, and had no knowledge or concern of pool supervision or safety.
Piles of safety violations could be reported to a pool manager painting her toe nails. But, little or nothing would be done until, a life was lost. Reminds me of Upper Big Branch Massey Coal April 5, 2010

A2 It seems the Fire Marshall and Dept of Health should have some teeth to enforce??? Or should they be toothless like MSHA???

Posted By: AaronS (7:38am 05-13-2010)
Report Abuse


That's like saying the Red Cross is liable for Life Guards they train, but were working under an incompetent pool manager, with no knowledge or concern of pool safety.

They should be if they're responsible for training the pool manager on pool safety.

I said we should transfer MSHA, health & safety, inspection & enforcement duties to the UMW

http://www.wvgazette.com/Opinion/OpEdCommentaries/201005030435

Would you also transfer protection of the chickens to the foxes because they kept the dogs out?

No one responsible for safety should be in charge of enforcement policies. That's about as stupid as having those responsible for enforcement conducting investigations of accidents.

Posted By: WVGazettereader (3:52am 05-13-2010)
Report Abuse


Posted By: AaronS “My recommendation was for the union to take... financial responsibility for lack of training and any enforcement problems and I told you the article to find it at.”

I can’t find it. Before my time?? I’m new to posting, and still learning to navigate. Maybe some day I’ll even learn to edit with italics, bold, and underlines???

It really saddens me that I missed this recommendation, as I try to read your posts. But, even if I had read this one, I’m not sure we were saying the same thing.

I said we should transfer MSHA, health & safety, inspection & enforcement duties to the UMW because of their track record om safety at union mines.

I may be wrong, but you seem to want to make the UMW liable “for lack of training and enforcement problems.” That's like saying the Red Cross is liable for Life Guards they train, but were working under an incompetent pool manager, with no knowledge or concern of pool safety.

Advertisement - Your ad here
Advertisement - Your ad here
nTelos Authorized Retailer - TruBlu Mobile
TruBlu Mobile is an nTelos Authorized Retailer located (Near the Mound) at 612 D Street, in South...
Advertisement - Your ad here