News
December 3, 2008
Ruthlawn Elementary students left wondering where to recycle
Advertisement - Your ad here

CHARLESTON, W.Va. - Ruthlawn Elementary School's second-grade students recycle paper, cans, glass bottles and plastic like it's second nature.

"They're going through my trash can," said second-grade teacher Rachel Fisk. "They're like, 'Hey, that's paper.'"

On Tuesday, Fisk asked the class how long it takes for glass to biodegrade in the earth's soil. "Four thousand years," one girl replied.

Principal Natalie Laliberty said the second-graders' environment-friendly efforts caught fire at home and across the school.

"They started something and the whole school kind of followed suit," Laliberty said. "Parents started bringing in newspaper and aluminum cans."

Fisk and Laliberty have found it difficult to tell the students why they might stop collecting plastics, glass and aluminum next week.

Last month, Norm Steenstra, director of the Kanawha County Solid Waste Authority, wrote to mayors across Kanawha County, saying that the agency would suspend collections of plastic, glass and cans for at least one month. Paper still will be collected.

Steenstra cited dramatic changes in the national and global markets for recyclables. He wrote that storage space is very limited at the Slack Street facility and "we are not able to market several items at this time."

He said Tuesday the suspension would affect few Kanawha County schools and the Solid Waste Authority would continue to collect plastics, glass and cans from all schools on its list, which include Capital and George Washington high schools, Piedmont and Overbrook elementary schools and others.

Still, the city of South Charleston picks up the recyclables at Ruthlawn, and will suspend its non-paper collections Friday.

"It's hard to tell 7- and 8-year-olds that sometimes the government and the economy can bind your hands and your hearts," Fisk said.

Advertisement - Your ad here
Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: smarbap (5:59pm 12-04-2008)
Report Abuse


concernedwv,

To state that recycling can "ensure the future of the planet" is laughable. With or without recycling, our planet will be just fine. As for the use of statistics, feel free to do the research if you like; this forum allows but 1000 characters.
And exactly what are the "risks" of free market capitalism? And since when is it a legitimate function of government schools to "instill values"?
The additional landfill space in WV illustrates how the free market works. Someone is making a profit while satisfying a need. The "natural spaces" are private property--not "ours".
Teaching across the curriculum? Whatever happened to teaching the actual curriculum? And if recycling is presented to a captive audience as something that will "save the planet," then it is the equivalent of teaching these students that 1 + 1 = 3. Schools have a fundamental duty to teach reading, writing, and math. Instilling values is the duty of parents and religion.

Posted By: concernedwv (12:38am 12-04-2008)
Report Abuse


smarbap,

It seems you are a bit uneducated on the risks of free market capitalism and the rewards of instilling values in our children to ensure the future of the planet they will inherit from us. Not to mention your lack of evidence. If you make a claim, please back it up with some statistics, not just personal anecdotes.
As for your landfill comment, America has more landfill space now because of the amount and size of landfills being procured, especially in our own state of WV (read: McDowell County) for use by out-of-state municipalities. We only have more landfill space because we have more and bigger landfills waiting for others' garbage to fill our natural spaces.
Finally, you should become familiar with what those in the education field call teaching across the curriculum. It is where you take one subject like recycling and educate students across the curriculum, reading, writing and math, based on that subject. Do some research and then start posting on this site

Posted By: smarbap (8:46pm 12-03-2008)
Report Abuse


Yet another example of how our wonderful, one-size-fits-all government school system works to indoctrinate students on the evils of capitalism. Recycling, like "global warming" is a complete fraud designed to weaken capitalism on behalf of alleged environmental concerns.
As a result of recycling, items that would normally be discarded now require countless gallons of water in order to be clean enough for recycling. And then there is the added environmental impact of recycling trucks, recycling centers, recycling machinery, production of those cute little plastic recycling bins, and the enormous cost of administrators and a continual public relations campaign.
The proponents of recycling like to state that landfill space is scarce. Nonsense! In reality, America today has a good deal more landfill space available than it did 10 years ago.
But none of this matters to those who desire to further their anti-capitalistic agenda at the expense of reading, writing, and mathematics.

Posted By: reader (7:43pm 12-03-2008)
Report Abuse


I agree, we need to find a way to support recycling through the ups and downs of the marketplace. There should be a floor of government support for all WV Solid waste athorities so they can continue recycling no matter what. I think the governor can make this happen if he wants.

It's easy to follow the top stories with home delivery of The Charleston Gazette.

Click here to order home delivery.

Advertisement - Your ad here